I’d say its risky to buy and hold the dong whereas holding gold would indicate a very stable “psychology”!
|
||
|
The Vietnam Government saga against its people’s preference for gold continues. Commodity Online reports that after the gold price “skyrocketed” the State Bank of Vietnam allowed private companies to import “5 tons of gold to help stabilise domestic markets and supplement local supply. … ‘Taking advantage of the situation, speculators in the domestic market had speculated, and manipulated, causing unstable psychology among people even though the amount of Gold in the market is still high’ [State Bank of Vietnam] said. The State Bank of Vietnam also said its consistent policy is to stabilize the dong’s value, and it is risky for people to buy and hold gold at the moment…”
I’d say its risky to buy and hold the dong whereas holding gold would indicate a very stable “psychology”! Commodity Online reports that the State Bank of Vietnam is putting further restrictions on gold lending and has asked commercial banks to cease lending gold and eventually to stop accepting gold deposits. “Vietnam has already forbidden banks from lending gold for the production and trade of gold bars since October last year. But starting May 1 banks are not allowed to offer gold loans to jewelry makers either.” “The new rule is an attempt to eliminate the role of gold as a means of payment in Vietnam, the central bank said. It noted that the government will, however, continue to recognize the right of citizens to have gold holdings.” “Gold holdings by the public were estimated to be about 400-500 tons then, said Vietnam Gold Association. Vietnam has been among a handful of countries in which banking sector takes gold deposits – bearing some interest – and lends gold as a lawful monetary means to bank borrowers. However, this practice may soon end with new regulations from the central bank.” Commodity Online has been reporting for some time about increasing restrictions on gold as its people increasing move to using gold instead of their fiat currency and with this latest move it sounds like Government sees a real threat brewing. I’ve had a view for some time that one will not wake up with gold suddenly banned – it will happen incrementally – and this behavior supports that view (although this could depend on country by country factors). Vietnam I think will be worth watching – we may well be seeing a loss of faith in fiat (hyperinflation) developing in a country where there is an existing use of and infrastructure of gold as money. How the Government responds could give some indication of how others will, but it is a unique situation as few countries have populations that familiar with gold. Interesting to contrast Vietnam’s approach with India (whose public is said to hold between 10,000 and 15,000 tonnes). Indian bullion dealer RiddiSiddhi Bullions Limited (RSBL) has just launched a gold account with the option of allowing RSBL to lend your gold out on your behalf. RSBL “will lend your bullion to various professional bullion market participants against adequate security … at the sole discretion of RSBL Commodities to decide whom to lend and for what time period.” As its fee, RSBL retains 10% of the income and will take liability for any defaults by borrowers. Note that the account is not targeted at the average investor with the minimum purchase size for gold being 1 kilo. On 26 November 2009 the State Bank of Vietnam devalued the dong by about 5%. This is the third instance of currency devaluation in two years. The FRN$ is likewise being devalued against gold. A few weeks ago I observed that those buying gold in Vietnam are paying a premium and that: Gold is money and is reasserting itself as currency in Vietnam. After 18 months of failed policies the helpless government has retreated from the import restrictions because the market is more powerful than governments.
Bloomberg reported, The State Bank of Vietnam set a dong reference rate for tomorrow that is 5.2 percent lower, at 17,961 per dollar, compared with 17,034 today, it said in a statement on its Web site. Policy makers narrowed the dong’s daily trading band to 3 percent, from 5 percent, effective tomorrow, and increased the benchmark interest rate for the first time since January, to 8 percent. GOLD PARTY GETTING STARTED As I observed on 9 September 2009 when the gold party was getting started, with the price at $995.75: 200 day relative price of gold is at 1.08x … Based on seasonal trends gold and silver will be strengthening, with the strongest months in September and November This upleg in gold and silver will have significant strength because of the long period of consolidation just like in 2004 and 2006 which provided the foundation for the uplegs in 2005 and 2007 that took gold from $400 to $700 and $650 to $1,000, respectively. If the current upleg is similar to the previous two then the 200 day relative prices for gold and silver at the top of this upleg would be about 1.5x and 1.7x, respectively. This puts $1,300 gold and $25 silver within range without greatly exceeding previous trading norms GOLD PARTY DUE FOR A BREAK On 25 November 2009 Reuters reported: Gold struck a record high for a second time this week, rising above $1,178 an ounce on Wednesday, as the dollar slipped and a newspaper reported that India was “open to buying” more gold from the International Monetary Fund. Gold has jumped nearly 13 percent since the beginning of this month as investors poured money into the precious metal after India’s central bank announced it had bought 200 tonnes of bullion from the IMF. The current price of gold is about $1,175 per ounce with silver at $18.70. Like I predicted November has been a strong month for both of the metals. The 200dma for gold is $967.86 and $14.73 for silver. This puts gold at 1.217x its 200dma and silver at 1.27x its 200dma. WHAT AND WHEN TO BUY Usually in a strong bull market silver will trail gold and then rapidly play catch up. The vast majority of silver’s gains happen in a relatively very short period of time. If gold is like owning a cruise ship then silver is like owning a speed boat. Because gold and silver have moved so quickly so fast, seasonality and the need for consolidation of these rapid gains therefore it is likely prudent to protect some gains while still maintaining exposure to the upside; for example, using put options. While over halfway there from when I predicted; I still think $1,300 gold and $25 silver is within range but there will likely be some correction and consolidation between here and there. Thus buying gold is not nearly as attractive as buying silver or even buying platinum which is up $340 per ounce since I recommended platinum about four months ago. I am still extremely bullish on platinum and if acquiring a physical store of the precious metals and given an efficient and cost effective option, such as with GoldMoney, between platinum, gold or silver then I would recommend platinum. SUPER DROOPY VIETNAM DONG WHEN PRICED IN GOLD With the 5.2 percent devaluation against the FRN$ and with the FRN$ losing nearly 13% against gold in November alone and $358 or 43% over the last 12 months the only conclusion is that the Vietnam dong is taking a beating when priced in gold. In other words, it has gone from 18.4M dong per ounce in January to a high of 28.85M or about 57%! With Vietnam’s widening trade deficit, the current account deficit, the demand for dollars and gold instead of droopy Vietnam dong, the global economic slowdown which will dampen exports (surely one of the reasons for the devaluation) and evaporating foreign exchange reserves therefore the monetary policy and condition of Vietnam will continue to erode which will place further pressure on the already droopy Vietnamese dong. CONCLUSION Vietnam is having a terrible time attempting to maintain their monetary policy. Economic law is being applied and gold is playing its prominent role like it always does. The government can resist but resistance is futile. Likewise the FRN$ is evaporating before the just heat of gold. Gold is nowhere near a bubble which is difficult to blow when when so much of the demand is fully paid for and not subject to margin call or default. But the real bubble is the FRN$ and demand is showing the first significant hints of declining. After all, it is becoming the carry-trade currency. Americans with the monetary metals will be as fortunate as Vietnamese because all the barbarous relics of fiat currencies are evaporating. The Great Credit Contraction has arrived and grinds on. DISCLOSURES: Long physical gold, silver, platinum and no position the problematic SLV or GLD ETFs. Back in June of 2008 after the Cambridge House Investment Conference I wrote about how Vietnam had limited gold imports but with all the updates to RunToGold it appears the article was lost to the Internet ether. The last time I was in Vietnam to visit a few factories, including one of Nike’s, I found the people so nice and gracious, learned about the mangosteen for the first time and had the best ice cream in the whole world. And the chocolate pancakes were amazing. The extremely low prices would amaze you. Bloomberg reported on 12 November 2009 that ‘Vietnam will resume gold imports for the first time since June 2008 … Five or six companies will be allowed to bring in unlimited amounts of gold’ [emphasis added]. The Vietnamese, like most in the East such as China, India, etc. have a severe case of gold bugitis. Vietnam, a tiny country of about 86 million people with an average per capita GDP of $1,042, is the largest gold retail investment country ahead of India. Of course, this is somewhat misleading because the GFMS distinguishes between jewelry and investment demand. GOLD TRADING AT ABOUT $1,300 PER OUNCE Bloomberg also reported: The price of gold in Vietnam was 27.5 million dong ($1,539) per tael today, according to a telephone directory information service run by Vietnam Posts & Telecommunications. It earlier reached a record high of more than 29 million per tael, online newswire Dan Tri reported, citing local jewelers. One tael is about 1.2 oz of gold. Some simple math reveals that $1,539/1.2=$1,282.50 or 29/27.5*$1,539/1.2=$1,352.45. VIETNAM DONG EVAPORATES The Vietnam Dong has been rapidly evaporating and losing their purchasing power. Many contracts, such as real estate sales, are being made using gold. Gold is money and is reasserting itself as currency in Vietnam. After 18 months of failed policies the helpless government has retreated from the import restrictions because the market is more powerful than governments. CONCLUSION Gold buyers in Vietnam have been buying gold at about $1,300 per ounce of physical gold in the spot market. The restriction on gold import restrictions by the Vietnamese government will lower the cost of gold in the Vietnamese spot market. We can assume, everything else being equal, that gold demand will increase because of the lower price. This is almost entirely real physical gold demand and not phantom paper products like the problematic GLD ETF or other tools of the gold cartel engaged in the central bank gold price suppression scheme. If the Vietnamese are willing to trade their paper illusions at such a discount then what happens when holders of the larger currencies that are lower in the liquidity pyramid decide to do the same? Oh wait, India already did and the gold price quickly jumped 5%. The Great Credit Contraction has just begun and the fiat currencies are hastening their evaporation. DISCLOSURES: Long physical gold, silver and platinum no position in the problematic SLV or GLD ETFs. |
||
|
Copyright © 2012 Citizen Economists - All Rights Reserved |
||
Most Popular Posts