This forum requires Javascript to be enabled for posting content

Current User: Guest Login
Please consider registering

Search Forums:



Oligopoly or a Free Market – A Realistic Choice?
Read original blog post

Add a New Topic
Reply to Post
User Post

1:49 pm
July 24, 2009

Stephan Zimmermann

New Member

posts 1

The study of economics should be clearly divided into its factual, quantifiable aspects (more commonly referred to as “econometrics”) distinct from the more philosophical and abstract study (generally known as ‘normative economics’). This is becoming increasingly important as the world has become ever more interdependent. The global financial crisis attests to this.

The argument in the United States increasingly rages between “free market” advocates, such as Friedrich von Hayek and Milton Friedman, and advocates of governmental social planning from Horace Mann to Barack Obama.

Vocal anarcho-capitalists would ideally do away with all forms of governmental influence or control, preferring a reliance on the sovereignty and sanctity of an individual’s decision-making ability. Ardent social planners would prefer to regulate everything from “Joe Six-Pack’s” beer consumption to private sex.

Few “free market” adherents attach economic importance to the desired social, racial or sexist equality that a majority of Americans espoused over the past fifty decades. These issues are perceived more in the realm of sociology or political science rather than economics. When the issues are addressed, it is often felt that the “free market” theory would solve them, just as Adam Smith and his “invisible hand” led the way to theoretical capitalistic freedom.

Unfortunately, the “free market” theory in the United States certainly did not, by itself, do away with the social injustices of segregation or discrimination, poverty or the exploitation of labor that plagued the country. It ultimately took government planners to lead society in what a majority of the country’s citizens considered proper.

Was a conscious exception made for state intervention on these issues to promote increased control for economic purposes?

Even more perplexing is the apparent lack of discussion of oligopolies in “free market” discourses.

Significantly more measurable than the normative verbiage about the“free market,” economists have achieved a number of factual measures to determine when an oligopoly exists. The “four firm concentration ratio,” the Herfindahl Index or other closely allied measures can show with little dispute than an oligopoly structure exists. Most economists agree that four or five companies controlling more than forty percent of an industry’s market share indicates an oligopoly market.

While collusion, pricing fixing or cartels have been illegal in the United States for a century or more, economists agree that “price leadership” in an oligopolistic structure is inevitable, as are upwardly rising prices an downwardly “sticky prices” despite a free market.

Oligopolistic firms are not generally controlled in the United States, unless there is clear evidence regarding collusion or other gross legal violations, such as safety laws.

Through most of last century, oligopolies maintained roughly forty percent of GNP. Through government deregulation during the early part of the nineteen eighties, however, oligopolies dropped to a mere eighteen percent.

However, there are few consumer goods that are not directly controlled by oligopolies. From airlines to automobiles to soft drinks, movie studios to fossil fuel energy and distribution, government action for deregulation helped, rather than hindered, oligopoly in the country. Sheer financial size dictate the difficulty of market entry.

Individuals and private companies, not government, foster the never-ending race to maximize profit margins, to outsource and downsize employee labor in favor of more efficient technologies, or to move physical manufacturing to less expensive nations.

The most competitive industries, however, such as apparel, furniture and – yes, the mortgage business – are those that most failed in the market..

Norman Jewison’s 1975 science fiction film “Rollerball” (and the panned 2002 remake) envisioned a world not run by politicians, but corporations. Only a handful of companies control the industries responsible for communications, energy, food, medicine, sports and so forth. Despite its violence, the film tries to point to the power of the individual versus either a state or a corporation.

If we accept today’ realistic global trends, oligopoly is likely to win over both: the concept of state monopolies or a stateless “free market” of some nine billion people.  Already American, European and Asian firms dominate their industries and compete within the structure of oligopolies irrespective of national political borders or mores. Their outlook on people’s wants is similar to Roman emphasis on bread and circuses.

Ideally, a fundamental change in the nature of mankind would solve the many pressing physical problems facing the globe. That, however, seems totally unrealistic.

Much of economics recognizes the facts of proven theories, instead of clinging to outdated, normative ones. It changes as the times change, albeit very slowly.

Read original blog post

9:10 pm
June 3, 2018



win like 96

pandora jewelry 70 off clearance

michael kors outlet

pandora bracelet

under armour outlet online

air max 2018

yeezy boost 350 v2

calvin klein outlet

nike outlet store online

curry 4 shoes

fenty puma

canada goose jackets

cheap nfl jerseys china

michael kors handbags outlet

air max 97 silver bullet

asics gel lyte

yeezy boost 350 v2

longchamp bags

pandora jewelry

valentino shoes

fake yeezy boost

christian louboutin mens shoes

vans store

off white jordan

red bottom

kyrie 4

curry shoes

supreme clothing

kd 10

clarks shoes for women

kobe bryant shoes

valentino outlet

vapor max

nike outlet store

skechers outlet

kd 10

michael kors outlet clearance

nike kd


canadian goose

supreme hoodie

red bottoms louboutin

rihanna puma

canadian goose jacket

pandora bracelet charms 

puma outlet

coach factory outlet

jimmy choo shoes

timberland shoes


louboutin boots

kate spade outlet

adidas yeezy boost



air max plus

ferragamo shoes

pandora bracelets clearance

vapormax flyknit

pandora charms

win like 82

lacoste polo shirts

tory burch outlet

north face clearance

jordan retro

birkenstock shoes

air max plus


jordan 11 win like 82

curry 4

adidas nmd

celine handbags

louboutin shoes

converse outlet

adidas outlet store

red bottoms for men

kate spade handbags

nike cortez

clarks shoes

kyrie 4

polo ralph lauren outlet

nmd r1

curry shoes

yeezy boost

red bottom heels

nike clearance

christian louboutin shoes

vapor max

cheap nike

birkenstock sandals

yeezy boost



fenty puma

pandora charms

yeezy beluga


gym red 11

pandora jewelry official site

canada goose sale

kobe 12

fake rolex watches

nike factory

birkin bags

pandora charms

lebron 15

yeezy boost 350 v2

jordan 11 win like 96

beats headphones

balenciaga sneakers

huaraches nike

cheap soccer cleats

curry basketball shoes

north face jackets


kd 10 shoes

jordan 11 red

birkin bag

pandora bracelet

north face jackets clearance

asics shoes

yeezy boost 350 v2

red bottom shoes

nike kyrie

louboutin mens

vapor max

clarks shoes for women

yeezy beluga 2.0

kyrie 3

fake yeezys

nike air vapormax

barbour jackets

kyrie 3

birkenstock outlet

red jordan 11

pandora rings

timberland outlet stores

tory burch handbags

jordan 11 red

the north face outlet online

salvatore ferragamo

jimmy choo outlet

replica rolex

balenciaga shoes

adidas ultra boost

ecco shoes for men

red 11s

salvatore ferragamo shoes

jordan 12

pandora jewelry

yeezy shoes

off white vapormax

calvin klein underwear

pandora canada

air jordan retro 11

calvin klein online

nike vapor max

birkenstock outlet

christian louboutin men

pandora rings

red bottoms

longchamp handbags

yeezy zebra v2

pandora charms

pandora charms sale

rihanna fenty puma

wholesale nfl jerseys

beats wireless

under armour clearance

louboutin shoes

asics gel


converse shoes

yeezy boost 350 v2

pandora bracelets clearance

coach handbags outlet

puma shoes

adidas outlet

nike air vapormax

adidas yeezy

nike vapor max plus

adidas outlet

goyard bags

red bottom shoes for women

vapormax plus

birkenstock sandals

nike factory store

nike air max 2018

soccer cleats

kyrie 3 basketball shoes

jordan retro 12

kd shoes


timberland outlet stores

replica watches

timberland outlet

ralph lauren factory store

pandora jewelry

kyrie 4 confetti

pandora jewelry outlet

pandora ring

adidas outlet online

nike kyrie 4

pandora jewelry

air max 97

pandora earrings

air max 2018



off white nike

the north face jackets

curry 4



lebron 15 shoes

adidas yeezy

pandora jewelry official site

nike clearance

huarache shoes

lacoste outlet

air max 97 ultra

coach outlet online

pandora bracelet

yeezy shoes

fitflops sale clearance

pandora necklace

nike air max plus

cheap nfl jerseys

pandora charm

red bottom shoes

kyrie irving shoes

adidas yeezy

birkenstock sandals


nike vapor max

wholesale jerseys china

red bottom

air max 97

skechers shoes

nike outlet online


yeezy blue tint

kyrie 4 confetti

louboutin outlet

off white shoes

michael kors canada

balenciaga triple s

curry 4 shoes

coach outlet

nike uptempo

asics running shoes

kevin durant shoes


yeezy zebra

fitflop sandals

coach outlet store

ultra boost

mbt shoes clearance

blue tint yeezy

fake yeezy

yeezy boost 350 v2

pandora sale



Reply to Post

Reply to Topic: Oligopoly or a Free Market – A Realistic Choice?

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Topic Reply:

Save New Post Smileys

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
9 + 2



About the Citizen Economists forum

Most Users Ever Online:


Currently Online:

4 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 1

Forums: 12

Topics: 1092

Posts: 1523


There are 1907 Members

There have been 142 Guests

There is 1 Admin

There are 0 Moderators

Top Posters:

Ajay Shah – 67

Christopher Briem – 59

Eldon Mast – 47

The Gold Report – 44

SimonGrey – 33

The Energy Report – 28

Administrators: B.P.T. (399 Posts)