This forum requires Javascript to be enabled for posting content

Current User: Guest Login
Please consider registering

Search Forums:



Can Private Health Insurance Work?
Read original blog post

Add a New Topic
Reply to Post
User Post

12:29 pm
September 18, 2009

David Barr


posts 3

Efforts to fix our health insurance system have found no found shortage of critical flaws in the “market”. I have yet to hear a coherent argument for the continued existence of private health insurance. Health care differs in three critical ways from traditional markets. Taken together I doubt that it is even conceivable for a private market to exist for health insurance.

In a true free market those who got sick and couldn’t afford care would be left to die or suffer the consequences of their conditions. This is a rational, yet morally abhorrent policy. Even the most die hard free marketers don’t advocate this. The unwillingness to condemn the poor to preventable death is the first significant obstacle to a functioning private health insurance market.

The second critical obstacle is the great variation in expected health care costs. Insurance markets are designed to protect individuals from significant deviations from expected costs. Consider auto insurance, every driver faces some risk or an accident, but few expect to total their car in a given year. By pooling risk, the small percentage of drivers that do suffer serious crashes can avoid financial ruin.

But this logic in no way applies to health insurance. Many people suffer conditions that have high known costs. If you are HIV positive or have Diabetes or are paraplegic medical costs are not an unexpected catastrophe, they are a known expense of life. Only the richest individuals can cover these costs out of pocket. Insurance can’t solve this problem only subsidies can.

Timing is the third critical difference between health insurance and traditional health markets. For insurance to function a claim must be tied to a specific instance. A fire, a car accident, a death are all discrete events that can be placed at a specific moment in time. The bulk of health care spending is spent treating chronic conditions. Who’s to say exactly when a person developed high blood pressure or depression. Furthermore, health conditions incur costs that continue long beyond the length of an insurance contract.

Efforts to twist private insurance around these three restraints are destined to produce warped markets and twisted incentives. The regulations currently oozing through congress will make life better for many people, but they do not address the fundamental incoherence of private health insurance.

Read original blog post

8:52 am
November 16, 2009



Very Well Said I appreciateCoolFrownSmileSurprisedWinkYell

4:25 am
August 23, 2010



posts 3


[url="" rel="dofollow"]Finance Jobs[/url]

4:25 am
February 1, 2011



It can work but I dont think all can afford getting that especially that there is an increase in unemployment in the country.

4:26 am
February 17, 2011



I definitely agree. Despite the efforts, there can really be no perfect system. There's always a downside. Criticisms are inevitable.

4:26 am
February 17, 2011



I definitely agree. Despite the efforts, there can really be no perfect system. There’s always a downside. Criticisms are inevitable.

9:24 pm
September 25, 2017



coach outlet storecheap mlb jerseyspandora jewelrycoach factory outletmichael kors ukmichael kors outletoakley sunglassesralph lauren outletred bottoms shoescoach canadamichael kors handbagshermes bagscanada goose jacketscanada goose jacketscoach factory outletcanada goose outletpolo ralph laurenmichael kors outletmoncler outletcheap jordan shoesugg outlet storeugg salecoach factory outlet onlinegucci outletugg bootslouis vuitton factory outletray ban sunglassesugg outletpandora outletugg outletcheap ugg bootstory burch outletcoach factorty outletcanada goose jacketsfitflopsyeezy 350 boostcanada goose outletpandora jewelrynike outletmichael kors factory outletralph lauren outletmulberry bagscheap jordans free shippinguggs clearancemichael kors outletcanada goose outletbeats by drecheap oakley sunglassesmichael kors outlet clearancelongchamp outletchristian louboutinpandora ukcoach outletnike shoesralph lauren sale clearanceuggs on saleray ban sunglassesmulberry handbagsugg outlet onlinehermes handbagscoach outletcheap ray ban sunglassescoach outlet storesuperdrylouis vuitton outletcoach outletnmd shoescanada goose clothinglongchamp handbagsbirkenstockstory burch outlet storekate spade handbagcanada goose coatsuggs outletralph lauren outletburberry salemulberry outletuggs on salejordansnike shoesmichael kors canadahermes handbagsugg outletraybanraybanugg outlet storehermes handbagsdiscount oakley sunglassesugg bootscheap ray ban sunglassesralph lauren uknike corteztoms outletcanada goose salecanada goose salecoach outletcheap uggscheap jerseys from chinaugg sandalscheap uggsugg ustraliapandora jewelrymichael kors outlet storecanada goose salecheap oakley sunglassesbirkenstock sandalspandora charmsadidas superstarred bottom shoeslouis vuitton outletoakley sunglassestimberland outletcheap uggscoach factory outletlongchamp ukcheap ray banslouis vuitton outletair jordanspolo ralph lauren outlet onlinecoach outletadidas outletmoncler jacketschristian louboutin outletugg outletpolo outletmulberry uknorth face outlet onlinecoach factory outletuggscheap jordanscoach outlet storeoakley sunglasseschristian louboutinpandora jewelryjordan retroadidas yeezyair max 2017coach factory outletadidas outletmlb jerseys wholesalepandoraralph lauren outlet onlinecoach outletmbt shoescanada goose outletmbt shoescoach factory outletugg bootsadidas shoesugg slippersray ban sunglassescanada goose ukcoach outletcoach outletjames harden shoesugg outletugg australiapolo ralph laurenpandora charms saleralph lauren outletcheap mlb jerseystoms shoes outletnorth face jacketsyeezy boostadidas yeezy boostpandora charmspolo ralph lauren outletred bottomslouis vuitton outlet storeadidas outletlouis vuitton outlet onlinevalentino shoesburberry salecoach outlethermes outletsupremeray ban sunglassesburberry outlet canadaburberry outletralph lauren outlet onlinemoncler outletkate spadeadidas yeezy boostcheap jerseyscheap uggscheap jordansvalentino shoes outletralph lauren outlet onlineugg outlettimberland bootsugg boots outletcoach factory outletnmd adidasugg salebirkenstock sandalspandora jewelrynike storecoach outletmoncler outletfred perrycoach factory outletugg bootsralph lauren outletugg boots canadamichael kors outletjordan shoeshermens bagscheap ugg bootstoms shoes outletpandora charmscoach outlet onlinecoach factory outletlongchamp ukfitflops saleugg boots for womenmichael kors outletadidas yeezyyeezy boost 350adidas nmdcoach outletpandora outletcanada goose outletnorth face outletmichael kors outlet clearancepandora charmscoach outletugg slippersmichael kors handbagsuggsmichael kors handbagsmichael kors handbagsralph lauren outletugg bootschristian louboutin outletpandora jewelry outletoakley sunglassestoms outletlongchamp handbagsmichael kors canadacanada goosecoach factory outletcoach outlet store onlineyeezy boostugg bootsadidas yeezyugg sandalschristian louboutin outletmoncler jackets outletburberry outletair jordan shoesmoncler outletlouboutin shoescoach factory outletlouis vuitton outlet storeugg boots on saleugg outletcanada goose coatsmichael kors outletadidas shoesugg shoeskate spaderalph lauren outletralph lauren outletugg bootspandora outletadidas yeezyharden vol 1canada goose outletmichael kors outlet storemoncler jacketskate spade bagsmoncler coatsnike air maxtoms shoespolo ralph lauren outlet onlinecoach outletcoach bagsralph lauren ukpandora charms salenmd adidashermes birkinugg outletcoach handbagsjordan retro 11coach factory outletnike outlet storeralph lauren outlet onlineadidas nmdmonclerralph lauren ukcheap jordansdoudoune monclercheap uggscoach outletralph lauren ukcheap nfl jerseysnike shoessalvatore ferragamolouboutin shoessupreme ukkate spade outlet storekate spade outletnike outlet onlineugg outletburberry handbagscoach outletmoncler outletpandora jewelrycoach factory outletpolo ralph laurenugg bootsultra boostmichael kors outletcoach outletcanada goose outletray ban sunglasses discountray ban sunglasses discounttoms shoespandora charms sale clearanceadidas nmdlouis vuitton outlet onlinepolo ralph lauren outlet onlineuggs canadaugg bootscoach factory outletugg bootscoach canadalouboutin shoesugg outletcheap oakley sunglassesmichael kors outletralph lauren sale clearancecoach outlet storeray ban sunglassesugg outlet storeyeezy boost 350ralph lauren outletchristian louboutincoach outletmichael kors outlet onlineugg shoespolo ralph laurenadidas shoeskate spade outletadidas superstarcoach outlet storediscount ray ban sunglassesmichael kors outletbeats by dr drecoach outletugg ustraliapolo ralph lauren outletcoach outlet onlinecheap nfl jerseys wholesalenike outletcoach outletbirkenstocksadidas nmdnike huaracheair max 2018michael kors outletlouis vuittoncheap mlb jerseysnfl jerseys wholesaleoakley sunglassesmlb jerseys cheappolo ralph lauren outletcheap nfl jerseyscoach factory outletcanada goose jacketschristian louboutin outletugg bootsugg outletcanada goose jacketslouis vuitton outletsalvatore ferragamo shoescoach outlettory burch outletair jordanscat bootsray ban sunglassesugg boots on salecanada goose salecoach outlet store online clearancescoach outletmichael kors outletpolo ralph lauren outlet onlineralph lauren sale clearancesuperdry ukcheap jordansmoncler jacketsmichael kors outlet onlinenike air maxpolo ralph lauren outlet onlineugg outletcheap jordansmichael kors outlet storecheap ray ban sunglasseslongchamp bagspandora charms sale clearancefred perry polougg outletkate spade handbagsmichael kors handbagscoach outletcanada goosenike shoes for mencoach factory outletralph lauren outletcanada goosemichael kors outletyeezy boost9.26linpingping

1:22 am
October 19, 2017



2017-10-19 xiaozheng6666

coach outletugg bootsugg outletcheap mlb jerseyslacoste shoescheap ray bansralph laurenadidas yeezy boostcoach outletadidas yeezy shoescanada goose outletcanada goose outletuggs outletcoach outlet onlinemichael kors outlet onlinecanada goose jacketskate spade handbagscoach outlet onlinecanada goose outlet storemichael kors outlet onlinemont blanc pens for salefred perry polomichael kors handbags salepandora outletmichael kors outlet onlinecheap uggsmichael kors handbags clearancepolo ralph laurencanada goose outlet storechristian louboutin salecoach outletugg boots outletcoach outlettrue religion jeans saleoakley sunglassesralph lauren uknfl jerseyspolo ralph laurentrue religion jeansmichael kors outlet onlineralph lauren sale clearanceugg outletcoach outletpolo outletmichael kors outletferragamo shoescanada gooseair jordan retromulberry handbagsvalentino outletray ban sunglasses wholesalemichael kors outletcoach outlet onlineed hardyray ban sunglassesmoncler jacketspolo ralph laurenchristian louboutin outletfred perry polocheap jordanscheap uggscheap oakley sunglassesralph laurencanada goose jacketscanada goose outletgiuseppe zanotti outletmichael kors outletcanada goose outlet storenike outletcheap jordans for salemulberry bagsuggs outletcoach outlet clearancepolo ralph lauren outletadidas yeezy shoesralph laurenmulberry outletpolo ralph lauren outletpolo ralph lauren outletcheap uggsmichael kors outlet clearanceadidas superstar shoescanada goose outlet storejordan retro shoeskate spade salecanada goose outlet storepolo outletmichael kors outlet onlinepandora jewelryugg outletcheap oakley sunglassescanada goose jacketspandora outletoakley sunglasses wholesalenike trainerscanada goose outlet storecanada goose jacketsmichael kors outletkate spade handbagscanada goose outletcheap uggsuggs outletcoach canadapandora charmsfitflops sandalsmichael kors outlet onlinekate spade pursescoach outletoakley sunglasses wholesalecanada goose outlet storemichael kors outletpandora outletcanada goose outletcanada goose outlet storeugg bootsmichael kors outlet storechristian louboutin shoesvintage nhl jerseysadidas outlet storeprada outlet storeralph lauren outletlongchamp outlet onlineferragamo outletnike outlet storecoach outletcanada goose jacketspolo outletcoach outlet onlinecoach factory outletcheap ray ban sunglassesmichael kors outletpolo ralph lauren factory storecanada goose outletcoach outlet onlineugg outletuggs outletcanada goose outlet storechristian louboutincanada goose outlet onlineralph lauren outletray ban pas cherasics shoesugg bootscoach outlet onlineugg outletnike shoes on saleoakley sunglassesprada outletugg outletcheap jordansmbt outletcheap nhl jerseysnike shoestory burch outletmont blanc pensmichael kors outlet clearancenike outletoakley sunglassesray ban sunglassescanada goose outlet storenike outlet storepolo ralph laurenadidas outletugg boots australiacanada goose jacketsralph lauren salecanada goose jackets salenike outletcoach factory outletoakley sunglasses wholesalepolo ralph laurenpolo ralph laurencanada goose jacketsmichael kors outletpolo ralph lauren outletfred perryfred perry polo shirtstory burch shoespolo ralph lauren outlet onlinegiuseppe zanotti shoesfitflop sandalsmichael kors outlet onlinecanada goose outletcheap ugg bootscanada goose outlet onlinemoncler jacketsralph lauren outletugg outlet onlinemichael kors outletmichael kors outlet onlinemichael kors handbagsralph lauren ukmichael kors outletpandora ringscheap ugg bootscanada goose outletcheap uggsmichael kors outletpandora jewelrycheap jordanspandora braceletmichael kors outlet onlinemichael kors outletpolo ralph lauren outlet onlinecheap ray ban sunglassesmichael kors outletcheap oakley sunglassesoakley sunglassescheap jordan shoespandora jewelryadidas outlet storemichael kors outlet onlinelongchampfred perry clothinguggs outletcheap ugg bootsmichael kors outlet storechristian louboutinmoncler outlet onlinenike factory storechristian louboutin shoescoach outlet store onlinemichael kors outlet onlineadidas yeezypandora outlet onlinemoncler outletchristian louboutin salembt shoes outletugg bootsnike shoes outletcanada goose outletmichael kors outletpandora jewelrypandora charmscheap mlb jerseyssnapbacks wholesalemichael kors outlet onlinecoach factory outletoakley sunglasses wholesalecheap ray ban sunglassesmichael kors outlet onlinegiuseppe zanotti sneakersralph lauren ukcoach outlet onlinepolo ralph laurencoach outlet store onlinechristian louboutin shoesadidas outletcanada goose outlet onlinepandora jewelrymoncler outletugg outletmichael kors handbagscheap ugg bootscanada goose outlet onlinecheap uggsmlb jerseys wholesaleoakley sunglasses wholesalecanada goose outletmulberry ukkate spade saleugg bootsfitflops salechristian louboutincoach outletmichael korscheap nfl jerseysyeezy boost 350 v2coach outlet store onlinecanada goose outletpandora ringshermes outletcanada goose jackets saleralph lauren polocheap uggsugg outletcanada goose jacketsfitflop sandalsmont blanccheap oakley sunglassesmoncler outletmichael kors outletfitflops clearanceugg outletmichael kors outletmichael kors outlet clearancemichael kors outlet clearanceoakley sunglasses wholesalemichael kors outletugg outletcanada goose outlet storenike outlet onlineugg bootsugg outlet onlinecanada goose outletkate spade handbagscanada goose outletmichael kors handbagscoach factory outletclarks shoeschristian louboutin shoespandora braceletugg bootspandora charmsair jordan shoesugg outlet onlinemoncler outletadidas nmdpolo shirts mencanada goose outletcheap ray ban sunglassescoach factory outletralph laurencanada goose jacketscoach factory outletcoach outlet onlinembt shoescanada goose salecanada goose outlet onlineugg bootslongchamp handbagsralph lauren shirtsugg bootstrue religion outlet storetory burch handbagscanada goosecoach outlet onlinefitflops shoespolo outletvalentino outlet storeralph laurenugg outletcanada goose outlet storecheap ugg bootsmoncler coatsralph lauren ukpandora outletpolo outletmbt outletnike shoespolo ralph lauren pas cherralph laurennhl jerseysnike shoesralph lauren outletugg outlet storeralph lauren pas cherpandora outletcanada goose outlet storepolo ralph laurentory burch outletralph lauren ukuggs outletmichael kors outletcheap uggspandora jewelry salepandora outlet storevalentino outletfred perry polokate spade bagscanada goose outletmlb jerseys wholesalemichael kors outletpolo outletnike outlet storemlb jerseysmichael kors outlet onlinefred perry polo shirtsuggs outletuggs outlet onlineultra boostscheap jerseys wholesaleray bans sunglasses outletcanada goose outlettrue religion jeansmichael kors outlet storecoach outlet onlineralph lauren pololongchamp bagsmont blanc outletmcm bagcoach outlet onlinecanada goose outletugg outletugg outlet onlinepolo shirtscoach factory outletray bancheap jordan shoespolo ralph lauren outlet onlineralph lauren polo shirtsadidas superstarcanada goose outletpolo ralph laurencheap nfl jerseysoakley sunglasses outlethermes birkinpolo shirtslacoste shirtsnike shoescoach outlet canadaray ban sunglasses on salecanada goose outlet storeuggs outletugg outletralph lauren outletmichael kors outlet clearancecoach factory outletfitflops sale clearancemichael kors outlet storetrue religion outletcanada goose jacketschristian louboutin ukcheap jordans for salepolo outletcoach outlet store onlinepolo ralph lauren outletpandora ringsmichael kors outlet clearanceadidas outlet onlinecoach factory outletralph laurenfitflops outletair jordan 4 retropolo ralph lauren outletugg outletpolo ralph laurenyeezy boostadidas shoescanada goose outletralph lauren polofitflop salepolo ralph lauren outlet onlineray ban sunglasses

9:18 pm
December 4, 2017



1:50 am
December 8, 2017



Reply to Post

Reply to Topic: Can Private Health Insurance Work?

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Topic Reply:

Save New Post Smileys

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
5 + 10



About the Citizen Economists forum

Most Users Ever Online:


Currently Online:

7 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 1

Forums: 12

Topics: 1066

Posts: 1384


There are 1907 Members

There have been 125 Guests

There is 1 Admin

There are 0 Moderators

Top Posters:

Ajay Shah – 67

Christopher Briem – 59

Eldon Mast – 47

The Gold Report – 44

SimonGrey – 33

The Energy Report – 28

Administrators: B.P.T. (399 Posts)